About this item
Our Paprikash Mustard is inspired by the Eastern European and Hungarian flavors of classic chicken paprikash. After a long wait, this customer-favorite condiment is back!
Sweet Noble Paprika leads with rich red pepper flavor, followed by a gentle warmth from Szegedi 178 Hot Paprika. Whole mustard seeds provide body and bite, while fresh bell peppers grown on an organic farm in upstate New York add natural sweetness and depth. Crescent Caraway brings an earthy, slightly sweet backbone that ties everything together and gives this mustard its unmistakable character. The result is savory, softly spicy and balanced.
Reach for Paprikash Mustard anytime you want a mustard that brings something different to the table. It’s dynamite in potato salad and deviled eggs, whisked with olive oil for a quick marinade for chicken or vegetables, stirred into creamy vinaigrette or spread onto hearty sandwiches. Once you open it, you’ll find plenty of reasons to keep it close at hand.
Customer reviews (7)
What customers say: This mustard offers a versatile savory, sweet, and subtly spicy flavor, praised for its unique profile in various dishes. Some found the caraway too dominant or the spice too mild.
★★★★☆
Good, but wish it was spicier
Nina M. · 2026-02-26 · Verified purchase
The flavor of this mustard is really unique and has a nice savory profile. I enjoyed the blend of bell peppers and paprika. However, I was hoping for a bit more heat from the hot paprika mentioned. It's only a very gentle warmth, so if you like things spicier, you might find it a little mild. Still a solid mustard for various uses.
★☆☆☆☆
Not for me
Nadia F. · 2026-03-17 · Verified purchase
I was excited for this but the taste just didn't work. The caraway was too strong for my preference, making it taste a bit too earthy and not enough like the Hungarian flavors I expected. It wasn't the sweet paprika forward flavor I was hoping for.
★★★★★
Excellent flavor profile
Joel P. · 2026-09-10 · Verified purchase
The balanced paprika and caraway flavors are incredible in this mustard.
★★★★★
Perfect for grilling
Mateo C. · 2026-04-02 · Verified purchase
We used this mustard as a glaze on pork ribs last weekend, and it was a hit! The paprika flavor really shined through without being overpowering. Will definitely buy again.
★★★★★
So good on sandwiches
Claire J. · 2026-10-11 · Verified purchase
This mustard is fantastic! It really elevates a simple turkey sandwich with its unique savory and slightly sweet notes. The whole mustard seeds add a great texture.