About this item
Color outside the lines.
A creamy, long-wearing eyeliner pencil that glides on smoothly with rich, buildable, blendable color, supplying endless options for creative expression. Go bold or get subtle with demi-matte, dense pigments for crisp, true color that won’t rub, tug or transfer. This soft (but never too soft!) formula goes on in seconds and easily creates a sharp, defined line, with just enough dry-down time to b lend it out for a diffused, smokey look—if that’s what you’re after.
• Inspired by the archives of art history, and calling for your own creativity, No. 1 Pencil’s 10 shades include a mix of bold and classic colors.
• Once the formula sets, it’s water-resistant, transfer-resistant and lasts up to 12 hours — so you can spend more time doing you, and less time doing touch ups.
Key ingredients :
Water and transfer-resistant (once set), No. 1 pencil is formulated to last up to 12 hours without touch-ups.
Product details:
• Buildable
• Longwearing
• Cruelty free
• Vegan
Dermatologist-tested, ophthalmologist-tested, water-resistant, suitable for contact lens wearers, suitable to wear on the water line, suitable for sensitive eyes
Customer reviews (16)
What customers say: Praised for smooth application, rich color, and a long-wearing, water-resistant formula that resists smudging. Some found sharp lines difficult and noted occasional waterline smudging.
★★★★★
Finally, a cruelty-free option that works!
Stephen J. · 2026-01-05 · Verified purchase
Finding a high-quality eyeliner that is also cruelty-free has been a challenge, but this pencil in Patina ticks all the boxes. The color is rich and buildable, allowing for both subtle and bold looks. It sets quickly and once it does, it's completely smudge-proof and water-resistant, which is essential for me. Very impressed with its performance and ethical credentials.
★★★★★
Long lasting and vibrant
Anna M. · 2025-12-14 · Verified purchase
I'm really impressed with how vibrant the Lapis color is and how long it lasts. It goes on without any tugging and stays put through my entire day. No need for touch-ups with this pencil.
★★★★☆
Good, but not super sharp
Evan C. · 2026-04-01 · Verified purchase
Applies nicely, but getting a super sharp wing is a bit tricky.
★★★★★
Excellent rich color
Lamar S. · 2025-10-21 · Verified purchase
The Ochre shade has fantastic color payoff, it's so rich and vibrant. It glides on effortlessly and provides a really crisp line. This pencil delivers exactly what it promises in terms of color and ease of use.
★★★★★
My new favorite eyeliner.
Nick H. · 2026-06-13 · Verified purchase
This pencil applies like a dream and the color payoff is fantastic.