Customer reviews (18)
What customers say: This eyeliner delivers intense color, smooth application, and long-lasting wear. Some found it occasionally smudges or fades, particularly if not waterproof.
★★★★☆
Nice intense shade
Dylan R. · 2026-01-20 · Verified purchase
The intense color payoff is definitely a highlight; the In Big Truffle shade is exactly what I wanted. It applies fairly smoothly, but sometimes I need to warm it up a little on my hand first to get the best glide. Overall, it lasts a long time, only occasionally needing a minor adjustment after several hours.
★★★★☆
Very precise lines
Angela T. · 2025-09-27
This eyeliner allows for incredibly precise lines, which is fantastic for detailed looks. The In Big Truffle color is deep and rich, giving great definition. While it says longwear, it can sometimes transfer a tiny bit on my upper lid by the end of a very long day, but it’s still one of the better ones I’ve used for staying power.
★★★★★
Smooth and vivid
Ethan S. · 2026-02-19 · Verified purchase
The application of this pencil eyeliner is incredibly smooth, and the In Big Truffle color is wonderfully vivid. It really makes my eyes pop and stays put for the entire day without needing any touch-ups.
★★★★☆
Good staying power
Becca P. · 2026-04-17 · Verified purchase
This eyeliner has pretty good staying power, usually lasting through my morning without issue. Sometimes by the evening, the shimmer finish can look a little faded. The color is still very vibrant initially.
★★★☆☆
Decent, but not longwear
Ethan H. · 2026-03-28
This pencil eyeliner has good pigment in the In Big Truffle shade, and it applies easily. However, I didn't find the longwear claim to be entirely true for me. It faded noticeably after a few hours, requiring reapplication.