CartivoShop with the AI assistant →
Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick
Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick — image 1Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick — image 2Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick — image 3Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick — image 4
ColourPop

Stay Jelly Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick

4.1 out of 5 · 12 reviews
$10.00
● In stock
  • Bold, multi-dimensional sparkle
  • One-swipe intensity, easily buildable
  • Effortless application with stick format
Free US shipping on orders over $75.00; otherwise $5.99 · 30-day returns · Sold by Cartivo (demo store — payments are simulated)

About this item

Own it. Stay Jelly is a rich magenta gel eyeshadow stick with gold, pink and violet sparkle — bold, multi-dimensional, and unabashedly itself. Swipe all over for a full statement lid or blend the edges for a softer berry glow. ✓ Vegan & Cruelty Free ✓ Jelly formula ✓ 1-swipe intensity ✓ Buildable

Specifications

FinishMulti-dimensional Sparkle
CoverageIntense, buildable
Wear TimeLong-wearing
Cruelty-freeYes, Vegan
Product TypeGel Eyeshadow Stick
Key IngredientsJelly formula

Customer reviews (12)

What customers say: This eyeshadow stick offers stunning multi-dimensional sparkle and intense, vibrant color that applies smoothly. The quick-setting jelly formula can make blending difficult or lead to creasing for some.
★★☆☆☆

Disappointing wear

Nadia R. · 2025-11-28

The initial application is beautiful with intense color, but I found it creased significantly on my eyelids after only a few hours. The 'long-wearing' claim didn't hold true for me, even without oily lids. It's a shame because the sparkle is lovely.

★★★★★

Fantastic pigment

Samantha W. · 2025-11-28 · Verified purchase

Gorgeous, bold color with amazing sparkle that truly lasts.

★★★☆☆

Good color, tricky application

Sanjay L. · 2025-12-05 · Verified purchase

I bought this for my daughter who loves experimenting with makeup. The magenta color is quite striking and the sparkle is definitely multi-dimensional as described. She found the jelly texture a bit hard to work with compared to powder shadows; it can be difficult to get an even application without it looking streaky. It's very vibrant, but she wished it was a little more forgiving during application.

★★★★☆

Vibrant and buildable

Sydney D. · 2025-11-04 · Verified purchase

The pink shade is very vibrant and the sparkle is beautiful. It's definitely buildable for more intense color. It stays pretty well, but I did notice a little bit of transfer if I touched my eye.

★★★★★

So pretty and easy to use

Abby P. · 2026-02-01 · Verified purchase

The multi-dimensional sparkle is incredible, especially in different lighting. It goes on incredibly smoothly and the pink shade is just gorgeous. Perfect for when I'm in a hurry but want a pop of color.