Customer reviews (16)
What customers say: This delicate ring is loved for its beautiful Herkimer diamond and comfortable fit, though some note concerns about sizing and the durability of the plating or stone setting.
★☆☆☆☆
Stone fell out quickly
Nadia T. · 2025-12-26 · Verified purchase
I was very disappointed. The Herkimer diamond fell out after only a couple of weeks of wearing it, which is unacceptable for something described as a keepsake. I really liked the look of it, but the quality is just not there for the stone setting.
★★★★★
My new favorite ring
Bianca W. · 2026-01-22 · Verified purchase
I've been looking for a simple, elegant ring with a unique stone, and this Herkimer Ring in 18K Gold is absolutely perfect. The diamond itself is incredibly clear and has such a brilliant sparkle. The thin band is really comfortable and doesn't feel bulky at all, which is important for me as I wear rings daily. I got a size 6, and it fits perfectly on my middle finger. It's a beautiful, delicate piece that I know I'll cherish.
★★★★☆
Beautiful but delicate
Deepa E. · 2025-09-05 · Verified purchase
I love the sparkle and unique look of the Herkimer diamond. It's a very pretty ring, and the sterling silver is bright. I do find the band to be extremely thin, making me a bit worried about its long-term durability for daily wear.
★★☆☆☆
Disappointed with finish
Tyler G. · 2026-07-13 · Verified purchase
I was excited for this ring, but the 18K gold plating started to dull and show signs of wear quicker than anticipated. It's a shame because the Herkimer diamond is really nice. Not sure if I just got a faulty one.
★★★★☆
Nice sparkle, decent quality
Mitch Z. · 2026-07-28
Looks good, the diamond really catches the light. The band is a bit thinner than I expected.